Live albums:
1970 Live (reissued 2005 with bonus tracks)
1996 Strawberry Jam (recorded 1966–1968)
East-West Live (recorded 1966–1967)
Live at Unicorn Coffee House (bootleg recording 1966)
1999 Live at Winterland Ballroom — Paul Butterfield's Better Days (recorded 1973)
2008 Rockpalast: Blues Rock Legends, Vol. 2 — Paul Butterfield Band (recorded 1978)
2011 Live at the Lone Star — Rick Danko, Richard Manuel & Paul Butterfield (recorded 1984)
Compilation albums:
1972 Golden Butter: The Best of the Butterfield Blues Band
1997 An Anthology: The Elektra Years
2000 Paul Butterfield's Better Days: Bearsville Anthology (Paul Butterfield's Better Days)
2006 Hi-Five: The Paul Butterfield Blues Band (EP)
Various artist compilation albums/videos and film appearances